lets look at the facts. main problems with underhood temps deal with intake temps and intercooler heat soak.
anyone who has an accessport can monitor intake temps and will see that a stock STI actually does pretty well under normal cruising conditions (50mph+) with intake temps not 15dF+\- or so above ambient. crusing 70dF ambient @ 70mph intake temps hardly reach 80dF. the real problem lies when we slow down or come to a stop. those numbers jump very quickly! we have no way to monitor intercooler temps but I have seen graphs showing similar results. I beleive Grimspeed has done reasearch with their TMIC.
this is what ive noticed under normal driving conditions, i dont see a need for it on a stock car. granted if your tracking ect, we are talking about a whole other world. maybe if your rotated and your filter is up in the engine bay, or you have a non cold air aintake ect. also food for thought, i think it was mentioned earlier, if you have a filter that sits down in that wheel well, will this have negative effects during wet driving conditions?
why did subaru decide to block this off? dunno. i just went out and checked my 2017 and ya, its completely sealed off - no give.