Tonight I was sitting at a redlight turning into a mall parking lot. A lady hit me from behind doing less than 5mph. It didn't even move the car, it just sounded like someone shut the trunk door hard or something. Upon inspection I found that there was one circular impression (From her Front Tag bolt) and a few small nicks/Scratches in the paint... It is on the passenger side of the bumper and the scratched area isn't more than 3" total. However, I'm a really picky person and I cant stand knowing that my bumper is scratched. The lady has insurance and we both use the same company (Allstate) The officers estimated under $500.00 in damage.. so what would you guys do? I will go crazy knowing that the scratches are there, so should I have the bumper painted? if so will they be able to match the blue? Can I get a bumper from Subaru Pre-Painted from the factory? if so how much would that be? I'm just kind of irritated right now. I haven't had my car for 2 weeks and already some careless dumbass decides to drive into the back of it while playing with her cell phone. Thanks for any help. Here is a pic of the main damage. There is also a small scratch right on the lip of the bumper right beside where the license plate mounts. Also, I'm out of town until next friday, but, I'd like to get the ball rolling on this first thing monday to get it fixed ASAP..