IW STi Forum banner

PSA: STi Invidia Q300 (new style) is NOT a quiet exhaust!

40K views 40 replies 26 participants last post by  BuzSTid  
#1 ·
Hi everyone,

Just wanted to share my experience as a 2009 STi hatch owner who recently installed an Invidia Q300 along with a catted Invidia DP. This post is also sparked by a 90 minute highway ride that has left my ears ringing.

Simply put, the exhaust is too loud for my taste. And to be honest I'm still a little baffled at all the research I did scouring the forums, hearing first hand anecdotal experiences and watching tons of videos (for what its worth) regarding the Q300 and its supposed QUIET exhaust. My biggest downfall perhaps is not actually meeting up with someone who had performed the exact same install. But even that, might not have proved useful. Let me explain.

For months now I have been eyeing the Q300 as the "civilized" choice for an exhaust upgrade. I was looking for a slightly louder than stock sound with an improved note under heavy throttle. This exhaust has often been clumped together with the likes of the Maddad Whisper and Borla Hush (among others). This is what I was told it would look like:

Image


Dubbed the "kitchen sink exhaust", the pipe entry into the muffler has always been characterized as unusual and is often criticized. Regardless, I'm fairly certain all that I read and heard about this exhaust, was in regards to this particular design. Let's call it the Q300 v1.

This is what I got:

Image


More photos here: Invidia Q300 Exhaust, new style, GR Hatch

The muffler is now on a slight angle and much closer to the rear of the car to allow the pipe to enter from the side. The adjustable tips (for length) are gone as well, and instead sit nearly flush with the diffuser. Overall, the Q300 v2 is a cleaner design and appears to be an improvement over the original. Looks awesome!

However, I have a hunch that this has also affected the acoustics of the exhaust. I was never expecting this exhaust to sound bass-ey in the cabin, but at anything between 1500 - 3000 rpm, it carries a nasty deep boom. At highways speeds, anything under load (going up hill or a car full of people), it is not just boomy but also pretty darn loud!

I set off car alarm warnings at low revs, and forget about going over 1500 rpm in a parking garage, unless you want to set off alarms 100 feet away. After about 3 months, I think it's actually getting louder too.

Only recently have I started coming across new style Q300 owners who seems to share my belief. There was a Maddad Whisper thread where 2 seperated Q300 spoke up about trading their exhaust for a Whisper (only to have tons of fitment issues). Another thread had someone's daughter complain about her "ears hurting".

Could a change in piping between v1 and v2 like that actually affect the sound so drastically? Or am I unreasonably expecting too little sound from a 3" design ?

I've been offered a few solutions. Obviously a full catback swap is one option, but I honestly can't seem to come across one that looks, sounds and installs as nicely as I would like it too.

I've also been told that equal length headers would reduce the boom. Is this true ?

I'm strongly considering going back to the stock catback, leave the Invidia DP, and perform another Protune, but I've been told that only the 2011 STi will put out good numbers with a stock catback, 3" DP and a CAI (approx. 300 whp / 345 wtq).

I'm also already in the process of performing a full QuietCar install. I've always wanted to do this for road noise reduction and a stereo install anyway, so maybe it will mute this exhaust as well. I can report back if people are interested.

I know this is all subjective, but I really feel like I didn't get what I thought I ordered. For people who are in the same boat as I was, let this be your warning.

I apologize for the long winded post. Feedback is always welcome. Thanks for reading!

Ken
 
#2 ·
Well, don't hope on the sound deadener to do much to the bassy drone. The sound is resonating inside of the cabin because of the size of it, not because its vibrating against it. You'd have to fill your whole hatch with acoustic foam to get a measurable difference... if that.

Check for exhaust leaks! Those will make it drone so much more. I had exhaust leaks in my magnaflow before I got rid of it, in hindsight, if I would've fixed the leaks it would've been a DD exhaust. Waiting on my fujitsubo (supposed to be THE quietest exhaust).
 
#4 · (Edited)
The interesting thing I forgot to mention is that the drone/boom is much less prevalent in the rear seat. You certainly hear the exhaust, but you don't feel the ear-clogging boom.

In fact, the closer I place my head to the windshield, the louder it is. It must be the way the sound is collecting and bouncing off the windshield. For that reason, I'm hoping the QuiteCar might actually make a difference, in being able to defuse the resonating in the cabin and disturb whatever is happening near the front.

Check for exhaust leaks! Those will make it drone so much more. I had exhaust leaks in my magnaflow before I got rid of it, in hindsight, if I would've fixed the leaks it would've been a DD exhaust. Waiting on my fujitsubo (supposed to be THE quietest exhaust).
I didn't perform the install myself but I was there for it. No shortcuts were taken with gaskets and there were no issues with fitment whatsoever. And I 100% trust the mechanics work. So I'm fairly certain there are no leaks.

So, my conclusion is that, while a VERY well built system, the Q300 lacks any real engineering or development of the sound.
I totally agree with you ... I love the quality, build and look of this exhaust, it's just a shame about the intensity of the sound.
 
#3 ·
I'm speaking from experience with the Q300 on an '06, so not 100% the same situation, but I had the same result. Got the exhaust and immediately noticed the ear pummeling low frequency boom. I actually got dizzy on the ride home the first day because of the low low frequency content. So, my conclusion is that, while a VERY well built system, the Q300 lacks any real engineering or development of the sound.
 
#6 ·
Yes, it is VERY bass-ey. It's not loud at all on the highway IMO (or anything over 3K rpm), but when it's warming up in my garage in the morning, it almost shakes things off the wall in bathroom above garage. People comment about the bass whenever it's their first time in my car, but like anything else, I've gotten used to it and plan on keeping it on long-term. Good luck, I've seen some people here on the forum go to a reputable muffler shop and have another resonator (ex: magnaflow hushpower resonator) welded into the mid-pipe to quiet things down... just fyi
 
#7 ·
... I've seen some people here on the forum go to a reputable muffler shop and have another resonator (ex: magnaflow hushpower resonator) welded into the mid-pipe to quiet things down... just fyi
This is another option I've given strong consideration for, but it seems like such a shame to start hacking up this well-built piping. I would expect the weld quality for the resonator to be on par with what Invidia provides.

Also, would this affect airflow at all, and as result, my Protune?
 
#8 ·
Ill take it!
 
#11 ·
Do you have this new style v2 Q300? And you don't find the boom headache inducing? The only time I'd consider the exhaust quiet is under light throttle at highway speed with windows up. Not decelerating or accelerating; it's a fine line.

Anything over 3k rpm is great though!
 
#13 ·
Wierd I read it was fine and it is also resonated?

I wonder how it compares to my old harman motive exhaust...

EDIT: I see you have a 5dr...most reviews I was talking about are from folks with the sedan which makes sense since they have a rear deck lid and two mufflers.

If that is too loud for you I strongly recommend getting the Harman Motive exhaust. I had it on my car for 2 years and loved it.
 
#14 ·
Okay, so just to make sure, I'm going to check for exhaust leaks this weekend. Before I do that, I have a few questions.

The reason I actually have a renewed interest in checking for a leak, is because of something I noticed on the highway a few days back. And the boom in the cabin reminds me a bit of when I had a leak on an older Subaru.

Let me know if this is normal, but going approx. 60 mph with the revs roughly at 2500+, I decided to gun it to REALLY exaggerate the low rev WOT boom. Now, I know that at that speed and rev range the engine will labour a bit trying to accelerate. I would obviously downshift under normal circumstances.

After getting a little closer to 3000 rpm, there's a fairly loud constant fluttering sound closer to the engine (and me), and the exhaust rattles quite a bit at the rear. Could this be a sign of an exhaust leak ? Or are these just other sounds that have always been there but are exaggerated by the turbo-back?

And when I go to check for a leak, does anybody know what gaskets the Q300 came with (I didn't perform the install)? I bought a turbo to downpipe gasket for the Invidia DP, but I'm just wondering where else I should make sure a gasket is used ?

Should all 3 connections (DP to mid-pipe, mid-pipe to rear-diff wrap-around pipe, and the connection to the axle-back/muffler) have gaskets ?

Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!
 
#15 ·
Okay, so just to make sure, I'm going to check for exhaust leaks this weekend. Before I do that, I have a few questions.

The reason I actually have a renewed interest in checking for a leak, is because of something I noticed on the highway a few days back. And the boom in the cabin reminds me a bit of when I had a leak on an older Subaru.

Let me know if this is normal, but going approx. 60 mph with the revs roughly at 2500+, I decided to gun it to REALLY exaggerate the low rev WOT boom. Now, I know that at that speed and rev range the engine will labour a bit trying to accelerate. I would obviously downshift under normal circumstances.

After getting a little closer to 3000 rpm, there's a fairly loud constant fluttering sound closer to the engine (and me), and the exhaust rattles quite a bit at the rear. Could this be a sign of an exhaust leak ? Or are these just other sounds that have always been there but are exaggerated by the turbo-back?

And when I go to check for a leak, does anybody know what gaskets the Q300 came with (I didn't perform the install)? I bought a turbo to downpipe gasket for the Invidia DP, but I'm just wondering where else I should make sure a gasket is used ?

Should all 3 connections (DP to mid-pipe, mid-pipe to rear-diff wrap-around pipe, and the connection to the axle-back/muffler) have gaskets ?

Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!
Usually you can hear an exhaust leak even in idle. From what you're describing, it kinda sounds like wastegate flutter (which is normal).

As for the gaskets, there needs to be a gasket on each connection. Turbo to downpipe, downpipe to exhaust and the other connections on the exhaust.
 
#16 ·
I love how my Q300 sounds but the "boom" you describe under 3k... well i feel the same way.

It actually doesn't bother me much at all operating the car under 3k. Problem is at startup! Super loud... with an abnoxious "tinny" sounding noise like something might be loose in the muffler? I don't know... have you noticed this? I only noticed when i stepped behind my car the other day right after a cold start.
 
#19 ·
Problem is at startup! Super loud... with an abnoxious "tinny" sounding noise like something might be loose in the muffler? I don't know... have you noticed this? I only noticed when i stepped behind my car the other day right after a cold start.
Yeah I have the same thing on cold starts. Its almost a rattling sound as if metal is vibrating against metal, but I can't seem to see any contact point under the car so it must the muffler/exhaust itself making that noise.

I've just trained myself to rev the engine slightly a few seconds after starting up, and it quickly lowers to just below 1k.
 
#17 · (Edited)
I wouldnt change my plans based on one review guys. I have the new style on my 08 with not a single complaint. In town driving to doing 3hr highway driving. I can easily listen to the radio on lvl 20 and hear every beat, have no issues with low bass drones. Just love the sound. Its personal preferance and of course everyone has a differant sensitivity to sound pitches/levels.
 
#30 ·
Its personal preferance and of course everyone has a differant sensitivity to sound pitches/levels.
It's by no means quiet, but you guys make it sound like it's soul crushingly loud. it's not THAT bad.
I agree. My reaction really comes from doing a fair amount of research and being told that the exhaust is "only a little louder than stock".

The more accurate description, and one I've come across more recently, is that it is NOT a quiet exhaust, but it's also NOT obnoxiously loud.
 
#18 ·
The 2011 sedan stock exhaust has a resonating boom at about 1500 rpm. I think the sedan is alot louder than the hatchback from the factory. When i see a hatchback drive by with stock exhaust i cant hear anything at all. The sedan owners might just be use to the louder exhaust so the next step up doesn't seem as bad?
 
#20 ·
Yeah, I put one on over the weekend. Catted DP, Q300 V2 on a 2011 hatch.

It was louder than I expected. I have no rattles though, and it isn't headache inducing. It did alter the way I drive casually though, I just shift a little earlier and don't give it as much gas. It's by no means quiet, but you guys make it sound like it's soul crushingly loud. it's not THAT bad.

If I had my way, I might tone it down a HAIR. But I like the bass, and I like that it emphasizes the "boxer sound" of the unequal length headers.

BTW: My 2 year old LOVES it. Giggles like a maniac if I give it gas, and yells "faster faster" if I don't. :lol:
 
#22 ·
I had this exhaust as well, it's loud on a hatch. Most cbe's are loud on the hatch due to the acoustics having a hatchback provides. I did some sound deadening in the trunk, it helped a bit. Now I have a perrin, that too is loud. I don't think a quiet aftermarket exhaust exists..
 
#27 ·
I had this exhaust as well, it's loud on a hatch. Most cbe's are loud on the hatch due to the acoustics having a hatchback provides. I did some sound deadening in the trunk, it helped a bit. Now I have a perrin, that too is loud. I don't think a quiet aftermarket exhaust exists..
Harman Motive....

I had it for 2 years and it was fantastic. Zero drone/boom, and loud when I needed it.
 
#23 ·
If you think the Q300 (V1 or V2) is loud, stay the heck away from TITEK! :lol:

Welding in a resonator should help a lot with drone. Or if you get fed up, try a Fujitsubo. I had one before I bought my TITEK, and it is a very very civil exhaust. It looks great, unleashes the boxer rumble, but doesn't drone at all. It was too quiet for me, which is why I went to the TITEK.
 
#24 ·
If you think the Q300 (V1 or V2) is loud, stay the heck away from TITEK! :lol:

Welding in a resonator should help a lot with drone. Or if you get fed up, try a Fujitsubo. I had one before I bought my TITEK, and it is a very very civil exhaust. It looks great, unleashes the boxer rumble, but doesn't drone at all. It was too quiet for me, which is why I went to the TITEK.
One of the downsides of running a light exhaust. The exhaust walls are thinner therefore making the exhaust louder.
 
#25 ·
+1 for Fujitsubo! I absolutely love mine. No drone at any rpm's and it gives off the perfect tone imo. But unfortunately they're no longer made. So you're gonna have a tough time finding one new.

Bonky, you went polar opposites! :lol:
 
#28 ·
#34 ·
I had the old Q300 and it was the perfect daily driving exhaust. I went to a ultimate Race and its seriously 5 times louder even with a resionator.
I feel like I am starting Subarus rally car every morning. I love it, but I think my neighbors dont:lol:
 
#36 ·
I had an HKS Legamax and LOVED it. I found the Magnaflow to be a bit too boomy and loved my HKS...sold it with my '08. I found an A'Pexi axleback on the cheap and slapped that on my '10 and that also is a great civilized exhaust, although a bit of boom at low revs.

I just picked up a Crawford Gymkhana and I don't know how the wife is going to react to it. My car now sounds downright evil. I think the A'Pexi is going to go back on...although I have the crazy of ides of swapping for weekends/trips and weekdays.

I think the bottom line is if at all possible, get first hand experience with the exhaust you want before you plunge for one.
 
#37 ·
Anyone have the Q300 with a Tomei EL header and Invidia Catted DP? I have the Header and DP and just purchased the Q300 which will be installed in a week along with a protune. Crossing my fingers, right now my car is really quiet.
 
#38 ·
I will have a very similar exhaust setup as what u said except my header will be AP EL length